| Bracelet | Manufacturer country | Battery life | Color display | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HONOR Band 5 | China | 5 days | Eat | 8.9 |
| Samsung Gear Fit2 Pro | South Korea | 2 days | Eat | 8.9 |
| HUAWEI Band 4e | China | 14 days | No | 8.8 |
| Xiaomi Mi Band 4 | China | 10 days | Eat | 8.8 |
| Honor Band 4 | China | 6 days | Eat | 8.8 |
| Honor Band 4 Running Edition | China | 10 days | No | 8.7 |
| Xiaomi Mi Band 3 | China | 11 days | No | 8.6 |
| Garmin Vivosmart 4 | USA | 4 days | Eat | 8.5 |
| Polar A370 | Finland | 2 days | Eat | 8.2 |
| LEMFO ID115 HR | China | 7 days | No | 8.2 |
In most cases, a pedometer in a fitness bracelet counts the owner’s steps based on a special device - an accelerometer (a device that determines the acceleration of an object). As a rule, fitness bracelets are equipped with three-component accelerometers that track acceleration along three coordinate axes. For more accurate readings, fitness bracelets can be supplemented with a gyroscope, which determines the orientation of an object in space. .
Thus, step information is determined based on the acceleration and position in space of your hand (in other words, based on the swing of your hand). That is, steps can be taken without even moving, but by actively waving your arms, or, on the contrary, steps are counted with a large error if the owner carries a heavy load or keeps his hand in his pocket while walking.
Therefore, the main goal in choosing a fitness bracelet is precisely the accuracy of the pedometer while walking (when your hands are not in your pockets and your movements are intense). All trackers will, in one way or another, count other types of activity as steps, which involve waving your arms and changing your body position. For you, we have selected fitness bracelets with a minimum percentage of false pedometer alarms and accurate counting of steps while walking and running.
Honor Band 5 - flagship from Huawei
Our ratings
Pedometer accuracy 9.3
Functionality 9.5
Display quality 9.8
Autonomy 7.0
Design 9.0
8.9 Average rating
Honor Band 5 is a rather high-profile new product of 2019, which was released immediately after the Xiaomi Mi Band 4. It seems that the model’s development time was cut specifically in order to be released at the same time as its main competitor. The fact is that Honor Band 5 is almost no different in design and technical equipment from the fourth version; the main metamorphoses have occurred with the interface and software. But even such small transformations were enough to instantly capture part of the market.
The device screen is the golden mean in the world of fitness trackers - 0.95 inches, AMOLED, 120x240 pixels, color, touchscreen. What's more pleasing is the change in interface design; it has become more colorful and voluminous. The notification text is easy to read, and the screen itself does not fade in bright light.
The software update allowed us to slightly increase the speed and accuracy of the device. But the old shortcomings remain: the maximum number of notifications is 10, when dialing which the tracker may begin to slow down, the battery remains the same (100 mAh) - with active use it will last for 5-6 days, dials have been added, but there are only 8 of them, Bluetooth 4.2 instead of the current version 5.0.
But the fitness bracelet also has a whole lot of advantages: 10 training modes, high water resistance and detailed swimming analysis, the best sleep monitoring on the market, a smart alarm clock, blood oxygen level measurement, a relatively accurate heart rate monitor and constant heart rate measurement, a “find smartphone” function and much more.
The pedometer accuracy of the new Honor Band 5 is at a high level. I have been using the tracker for several weeks now, the results are as follows: the average error in counting steps is 2%; the average error in measuring the distance traveled is 6%; the bracelet does not count as steps when traveling on public transport; Driving and active gestures are also not taken into account by the pedometer. You will find detailed measurement results in a separate review (link below).
pros
- High quality strap with comfortable clasp
- Well-developed graphics in the interface
- Touch AMOLED display with protective 2.5D glass
- Detailed sleep monitoring
- Smart alarm clock
- 10 training modes
- Good accuracy of pedometer and heart rate monitor
- WR50 water resistance and detailed swim monitoring
- No need to remove the capsule to charge
Minuses
- The design is no different from the previous version of the bracelet
- Weak oleophobic coating - fingerprints remain on the screen
- Braking due to a large number of accumulated notifications
- Remote camera control is only available for Huawei smartphones
- NFC and AliPay do not work in Russia
- Bluetooth version 4.2
- Lack of built-in GPS
Samsung Gear Fit2 Pro - a combination of versatility and quality
Our ratings
Pedometer accuracy 8.8
Functionality 9.9
Display quality 9.9
Autonomy 6.0
Design 9.8
Ease of use with a smartphone 8.8
8.9 Average rating
A bright model with a very large 1.5-inch AMOLED display and a resolution of 432x216 pixels. It is the large display and high resolution that make this fitness bracelet the owner of the highest quality and most detailed screen on the tracker market.
Samsung Gear Fit2 Pro has many functions for tracking your health and physical activity: continuous heart rate counting, calorie counter, floor sensor, activity tracking during training, sleep monitoring, movement history, training plan, timer and stopwatch, etc. .
The gadget is also distinguished by the presence of many additional functions: reading all messages and notifications received on the phone, notification of a disconnection with the phone, sending template messages, viewing the weather, playing audio, etc.
The fitness bracelet is also equipped with built-in sensors: heart rate monitor, accelerometer, gyroscope, altimeter, GPS tracker.
The manufacturer placed special emphasis on using the device in the pool. The waterproof rating allows you to swim with the bracelet, and the device itself has a special sports mode for tracking activity in the water.
You need to be very careful with the bracelet. Many users complain that water gets into the device through cracks and chips that may have been caused by hitting a door frame, furniture, etc. Some people still advise against constantly swimming with such an expensive fitness bracelet.
During sports activity and walking, the pedometer shows accurate data - the error is less than 1%. In everyday life, he can add steps when active with his hands, such as while taking a shower, changing clothes, and active gestures.
pros
- Large, color display
- Wide range of functions
- GPS tracker
- Well-developed application
- Reliable strap
- Stylish design
Minuses
- High price
- Autonomy up to 2 days
- False pedometer alarms
- No smart alarm clock
Huawei Band 4e – tracker for running and basketball
Our ratings
Pedometer accuracy 9.4
Functionality 7.3
Display quality 9.0
Autonomy 8.4
Design 9.0
Ease of use with a smartphone 8.8
8.8 Average rating
Equipment: fitness bracelet, shoe mount, charger, documentation. Using a special clothespin, the tracker can be securely attached to shoes for more detailed activity monitoring.
The bracelet is compact (14.8x40.5x11.2 mm) and light (13 grams). But despite its small dimensions, the device looks stylish on the hand.
The main module is fixed in a silicone block to which the strap is attached. The module can be easily removed with little effort.
Separately, it is worth noting the unusual fabric strap, which is made from recycled materials. This bracelet does not cause irritation or allergic reactions, so it will be an excellent replacement for silicone straps.
The screen is non-touch, the interface is controlled using the touch button at the bottom of the module.
It is worth mentioning that Huawei Band 4e can only notify you about messages; you cannot read the text or find out the sender’s name on the bracelet. Notification of incoming calls is also available.
Basketball Wizard Edition is in the name of the fitness bracelet for a reason. Huawei Band 4 can not only track the user’s basketball activity, but also provides detailed statistics: the number and height of jumps, maximum and average height of jumps, duration of freezes, speed of movement, duration of the game, distance traveled, number of steps, calories burned. After the game, the tracker calculates its effectiveness in points.
This device also pays a lot of attention to running. In the statistics you can see the following parameters: average pace, average speed, stride length, average time of contact with the ground, average push, average turnout, average elevation angle.
The pedometer error is less than 5%. Test results while walking: took 100 steps, the bracelet counted 103; took 300 steps, the bracelet counted 309.
pros
- Compact and lightweight
- 2 wearing modes: on the arm and on the leg
- Low cost
- Hypoallergenic strap
- Detailed analysis of running activity
- Water resistance 5ATM
- There is a "Basketball" mode
- Accuracy of work
Minuses
- No heart rate sensor
- Small monochrome screen
- Notification text cannot be read
- Narrow specialization: for running and basketball
Xiaomi Mi Smart Band 4 – the best fitness bracelet of 2019
Our ratings
Pedometer accuracy 8.9
Functionality 9.0
Display quality 9.8
Autonomy 8.0
Design 9.1
Ease of use with a smartphone 9.0
8.8 Average rating
Where to buy in Moscow and regions:
Xiaomi Mi Smart Band 4 is one of the most anticipated fitness bracelets in 2019. The fourth Mi Band is definitely the best offer on the fitness tracker market in terms of price/functionality/quality ratio.
Mi Band 4, compared to the previous version of the bracelet, received a new processor, a new screen, an updated sensor, 2.5D protective glass, a 3-axis gyroscope, and an increased battery capacity. We couldn't do without additional functionality. Now the fitness bracelet can analyze 6 types of activity, constantly monitor your heart rate, control your smartphone’s player, provide a weather forecast for 4 days in advance, and change the design of the main screen.
The Mi Band 4 features an updated Huangshan No. 1 processor, as well as a 3-axis accelerometer and 3-axis gyroscope. These technical innovations allow the fitness bracelet not only to work faster, but also to provide more detailed and accurate data about your activity.
In terms of step counting, Xiaomi Mi Band 4 cannot be called the most accurate fitness bracelet. Steps, as before, measures plus and minus adequately, but not without errors. The fact is that counting steps is too individual an indicator, which depends not only on the length of your step, but also on the movements of your hands while walking.
I conducted an experiment in which I took exactly 1000 steps, which the tracker counted as 991. This is a very impressive result, but not everyone gets it. After reading reviews from other users and comparing their numbers, I came up with a maximum error of 15%. That is, in the worst case, with real 1000 steps, the bracelet will be wrong by 150.
Unfortunately, the bracelet still cannot count the number of floors passed - this is also a minus.
Read about the heart rate monitor of the fitness bracelet, its functionality, as well as other pros and cons in the full review of the Mi Band 4:
pros
- Laconic and discreet design (perfect for any clothes)
- Lightweight and compact, comfortable to wear
- Protective 2.5D glass
- Bright and informative display
- Autonomy from 10 to 20 days
- A large number of sports modes
- Voyage accounting
- Possibility to choose a suitable dial design
- 4 day weather forecast
- Smartphone player control (volume adjustment, track switching, pause)
- Moisture protection version WR50 (swimming, shower)
- Accurately measures resting heart rate (1-2% error)
- Low cost
Minuses
- The bracelet cannot track daytime sleep
- Notification font is too small
- Error in pulse measurement after 150 beats/min
- To charge the bracelet, you must remove the capsule from the strap.
- The strap clasp may come loose from time to time.
- No built-in GPS sensor
- Lack of smart alarm clock
- The “swimming” training mode is poorly developed (there is an error in measurements, meager statistics)
- In Russia there is no support for NFC and voice assistant
Honor Band 4 – the choice of buyers
Our ratings
Pedometer accuracy 9.0
Functionality 8.9
Display quality 9.8
Autonomy 7.5
Design 9.0
Ease of use with a smartphone 8.6
8.8 Average rating
A beautiful model with a large color AMOLED display, 0.94 inches diagonal and a resolution of 240x120 pixels, which gives one of the highest quality images on the tracker market.
The Honor Band 4 bracelet is characterized by a large set of functions: controlling the camera from the phone, searching for a phone, viewing notifications, heart rate monitor, blood pressure monitor (including the ability to set up constant measurements), sleep monitoring, smart alarm clock and much more. All declared functions work accurately, without large errors.
The WR50 water resistance allows you to take the bracelet into the pool. In addition, the application has a special “swimming” mode that will provide detailed statistics on your swims.
When viewing notifications, the gadget begins to freeze a little, which is most likely due to a lack of memory.
The pedometer shows accurate information. Including, in the sports mode “Swimming” it counts strokes with arms in different styles: breaststroke, backstroke, etc. You can manually set a goal: a certain number of steps per day. But here it should be taken into account that steps will be counted optimally, for example, when jogging, when the movements are monotonous. During normal walking from work to home, an error of 10-200 steps per 1000 real ones may occur. This is explained by the fact that the bracelet may mistakenly count some hand movements and bends as steps.
There is a delay in updating steps on the bracelet screen. It is recommended to analyze the statistics step by step at the end of the day, then the error will be minimal.
pros
- High-quality assembly and reliability
- Absolutely waterproof
- Large and high-quality display
- Wide range of functions
- Up to 6 days of battery life with active use
- The display is protected by tempered glass
Minuses
- “freezing” when there are a large number of accumulated messages
- No GPS tracker
- Small selection of watch faces for the home screen
- There is no way to control music on the phone
Honor Band 4 Running Edition – the best solution for running
Our ratings
Pedometer accuracy 9.4
Functionality 7.5
Display quality 9.0
Autonomy 8.0
Design 8.0
Ease of use with a smartphone 8.4
8.7 Average rating
Honor Band 4 Running Edition is a special line of bracelets designed for running, so the device comes with a plastic attachment for attaching to shoes.
The hypoallergenic strap is pleasant to the touch and does not look cheap. The classic buckle clasp securely secures the bracelet on your hand. Available in 5 strap colors. The main module with the screen is easily pulled out of its slot thanks to the flexibility of the strap.
The monochrome P-OLED screen with a diagonal of 0.5 inches does not have a sensor, and all control is assigned to the touch button underneath it.
The model does not have a heart rate sensor, unlike its older brother (Honor Band 4). But the device is not without other functions: counting steps, distance traveled and calories, notifications from the phone, smart alarm clock, phone search, inactivity reminder, activating the screen by raising the wrist and switching menu items by turning the hand.
You can set up to receive notifications from any application, but the bracelet will not show the message itself and the recipient of the shipment, it will only give a signal.
The 77 mAh battery allows the bracelet to operate in standby mode for 20 days, and with active use for about 10 days.
Now about the pedometer: the tracker does not count steps in the car or public transport, the error in counting accuracy is up to 4%. Tests: walked 100 steps, the bracelet showed 107, walked 500 steps, the bracelet showed 509, walked 1000 steps, the bracelet counted 1037.
The bracelet is designed for running, it can calculate the average pace, average speed, step length, average time of contact with the ground, average landing push, average eversion, average ascent angle, as well as perform analysis and make recommendations.
The error in calculating distance while jogging is usually up to 5%, but sometimes it can reach 10%. Tests: ran a circle of 400 meters, the bracelet showed 360; ran 1 km, the bracelet showed 1.04 km; ran 1.3 km, the bracelet showed 1.29 km.
pros
- Low price
- Waterproof WR50 (can swim and shower)
- Lightweight and compact
- Attractive design
- Shoe attachment
- Measuring a large number of running parameters
- Maintains connection with phone up to 40 meters
- Smart alarm clock
- More than a week without charging
- High accuracy
Minuses
- No heart rate sensor
- Small monochrome display
- Does not show notification text and recipient
- Not the most correct sleep monitoring
Xiaomi Mi Band 3 - the most affordable and popular bracelet
Our ratings
Pedometer accuracy 8.6
Functionality 8.0
Display quality 8.9
Autonomy 8.0
Design 8.9
Ease of use with a smartphone 9.0
8.6 Average rating
Where to buy in Moscow and regions:
A model with an oval, convex screen, which is why it sometimes clings to clothes and gets scratched. The strap is beautiful and comfortable, but it only snaps into place with one pin and can come unfastened at will.
The gadget from Xiaomi has a low price, but a decent set of functions. There is a heart rate monitor, sleep phase monitoring, phone search mode, calorie counter, notifications for increased heart rate and much more. But not all of the declared functions work as they should. For example, a heart rate monitor provides correct information only in rest mode. During load, the data may differ from reality by 20-30%.
In addition to being vulnerable to scratches, the device's screen displays information poorly in bright sunlight, which is largely due to the convex shape of the glass.
Mi Band takes steps into account based on the G-sensor and multiplies their number by the average step length, calculated based on your specified height. Thus, maximum accuracy in counting steps can be achieved only when moving with an average step length with normal arm movements (characteristic of walking).
During normal activity, the bracelet can read any movements of the arms or changes in body position as steps. In this case, the approximate error of the pedometer by the end of the day can reach 30 percent. In public transport, the tracker can count 300-500 steps on a 2-3 km road.
But there is still a way to increase the accuracy of the pedometer. To do this, you need to select any activity in the “Activity”, as a result of which your smartphone’s GPS will be connected, which will reduce the error in counting steps to negligible. But along with GPS, the bracelet’s heart rate monitor will also be turned on in the mode of constant heart rate measurements, which will negatively affect autonomy.
pros
- Low cost
- Wide range of functions
- Moisture protection according to WR50 standard (shower, swimming)
- Battery lasts 10-15 days
- Thoughtful application
- Weather widget
Minuses
- Inaccurate operation of the heart rate monitor during training
- Doesn't keep more than 5 notifications in memory
- The pedometer overestimates the real indicators
- Convex display sometimes gets scratched
Garmin Vivosmart 4 with stress and energy tracking
Our ratings
Pedometer accuracy 8.8
Functionality 9.5
Display quality 8.6
Autonomy 6.8
Design 9.3
Ease of use with a smartphone 8.2
8.5 Average rating
Lightweight, super-thin fitness bracelet with a comfortable silicone strap. The tracker does not cause any discomfort on the wrist and is comfortable to sleep with. The display is small but bright and automatically adjusts to ambient light levels. The bracelet design is a step forward for Garmin.
5ATM water resistance allows you to use the gadget even when swimming. A special Pulse Ox sensor is capable of assessing the level of oxygen in the blood at any time of the day. The device can also track stress and energy levels - you will know exactly when the body is ready for stress.
With active use, one charge of the fitness bracelet lasts for an average of 4 days. But if you turn the display brightness to maximum and start constantly measuring blood oxygen levels and pulse, the tracker will work for a little more than one day.
The bracelet accurately measures your heart rate at rest, but during physical activity, as the pace increases, the error of the heart rate monitor increases.
All standard functions for fitness bracelets are present: counting steps, measuring heart rate, setting goals, monitoring sleep, monitoring calories burned, receiving alerts and notifications, viewing the weather forecast, controlling the smartphone camera, finding a phone and much more. Vivosmart 4 is a truly multifunctional modern fitness tracker.
The disadvantages include the small screen, which makes it very difficult to read messages, and sometimes some of the text is not visible at all. In addition to the fact that the fitness bracelet for 16 thousand does not have a built-in GPS sensor, the ability to connect a smartphone to the GPS is also excluded. The quality of the display leaves much to be desired. In addition, some buyers note the low level of Russian support.
This device is perfect for those close to professional sports. Those for whom it is important not just to measure steps, but also to track basic health indicators, will like this gadget.
pros
- Comfortable thin bracelet
- Compact and lightweight gadget
- Measuring blood oxygen levels
- Waterproof 5 ATM
- Laconic design
- Accurate pedometer
- Innovative Body Battery energy monitoring function
- Advanced sleep monitoring metrics
- Multifunctionality
Smart watch with heart rate monitor Not uncommon in 2017, almost every smartwatch manufacturer has taken care of a heart rate sensor in their device. This is not surprising; the function is really necessary, and sometimes even critically important, especially for athletes and for people with heart disease. Athletes have a unique opportunity to regulate their training, adjusting to the appropriate heart rate zone depending on the training goal.
Such a huge assortment of smart watches with a heart rate monitor on the market makes the buyer at a loss in choosing, for this, to ease the pain of choice, we have made the TOP 7 smart sports watches with a heart rate sensor.
Herzband Elegance
Editor's rating: 
Average price – $70
Estimated life time: 5 days
Herzband is a brand that is confidently gaining popularity in the CIS, it has gained fame for its ability to measure pressure, or rather, calculate it based on heart rate readings. These are the best at the moment.
Design. They have a classic design, a round dial with a mechanical button on the right, a leather strap complements the classic ambience.
Functionality and characteristics. The display is monochrome and has a fairly low brightness reserve. The controls are convenient, they can be turned on by turning the wrist, but there is no voice control. Receive notifications from all messenger applications. Tracks all physical activity, like any other fitness tracker. They have a fairly low brightness reserve; in sunny weather it will be difficult to make out anything.
Our editorial testing has shown that The watch's heart rate monitor works properly.
Advantages:
- pressure measurement;
- stylish design
- low price
Flaws:
- low display brightness reserve
- no GPS
Verdict: A good option for those who are looking for a budget option for a smartwatch with a heart rate monitor that has a classic design and the functionality of a fitness tracker.
Editor's rating:
Average price – $200
Estimated life time: 25 days
Design and interface.Withings Steel HR has a truly “Swiss” watch design; it is only revealed by a small OLED display, which is designed to show all the watch’s notifications. Using a mechanical button, it switches between Withings Steel HR screens, where you can view your heart rate, steps and calories.
Functionality and characteristics. The main advantage of the watch is its record life time, which is 25 days in active mode, an incredible result for a modern smartwatch. To achieve such results, sacrifices had to be made, and this sacrifice was the display, which received a very small size. But it is worth noting that it copes with all its functions perfectly. Due to the bright backlight, all information is clearly perceived even on a small display.
Another interesting feature is the high water protection, which is 5 ATM. This allows the watch to be submerged to a depth of 50 meters. The watch is equipped with a soft silicone strap, which will allow you to dive with the watch in the pool and at sea.
The “brains” of the device are not too far behind the design and amaze with their functionality. So, they can independently determine what type of physical activity you are currently doing (paired with a connected smartphone), determine the stages of sleep, but without a smart alarm clock.
The operation of the heart rate monitor in the watch quite accurate, but during intense training the data is distorted.
Advantages:
- record life time
- stylish design
- high degree of protection against water
Flaws:
- inconvenient controls
- no GPS
- inconvenient charging
- The heart rate monitor does not cope with intense workouts
Verdict: An excellent option for a smartwatch with a heart rate monitor and pedometer for those who appreciate classic style and do not like to charge gadgets.
Editor's rating:
Average price – $150
Estimated life time: 11 days
Xiaomi AmazFit Pace is the first smartwatch from the famous Chinese brand, which went on sale quite recently, at the beginning of 2017. They have already gained a lot of fans around the world due to their stylish design and fitness tracker capabilities. In this review, we are interested in precisely these capabilities and, in particular, the operation of the heart rate monitor.
Functionality and characteristics. Xiaomi AmazFit is not just a smart watch with a heart rate monitor, it is also a good GPS-tracker, capable of tracking your movements. This combination of functionality should be appreciated by lovers of jogging in the fresh air. It should be noted here that when GPS is turned on, battery life is reduced from 5 days to one day, and in domestic use the manufacturer promises work up to 11 days, which is a very impressive indicator with such a display.
Another interesting feature of the watch is the presence of memory - 4 GB, where you can store music that you can listen to using a wireless headset.
Among other things, the watch has standard functions for tracking sleep, steps, and calories burned. There is no smart alarm clock, there is only a regular vibration alarm clock. Heart rate monitor operation I was very pleased; a series of comparative tests with chest heart rate monitors did not reveal any serious errors.
Design and interface. Xiaomi AmazFit Pace boasts a rich display where you can easily view basic data; the brightness is adjusted automatically due to the built-in sensor. At the same time, the display has a number of control disadvantages. First, the gadget does not support voice control, and second, to activate the display you need to press the small mechanical button in the upper right corner.
Like any smartwatch, Xiaomi AmazFit Pace can receive notifications from applications. Unfortunately, this area has not been fully developed. Thus, the “Reply” and “View conversation” functions do not function. The interface is presented only in English or Chinese.
Advantages:
- Availability of GPS
- high quality display
- long life time
Flaws:
- inconvenient display activation
- flawed notification software
- no support for Russian language
Verdict: An excellent option for those who prefer a sporty design and do a lot of outdoor activities.
Average price – $375
Estimated shelf life: up to 4 days
Design and interface. The watch was released in two design options, which are noticeably different, but at the same time quite similar. Samsung Gear S3 Frontier is a brutal version, similar to what we see on the covers of magazines with harsh models. The Samsung Gear S3 Classic is a timeless classic design, smaller than its larger sibling and not as shock and shock resistant, while the Frontier version is MIL-810G protected.
One of the main features and the main control feature of this watch is the “bezel”, this is a rotating ring around the watch, with the help of which gadgets are controlled. This solution turned out to be very successful and simplified interaction with the device by an order of magnitude.
The watch uses a standard strap that can be easily unfastened and replaced with yours. The body is made of high quality 316L steel.
Display with the SUPER AMOLED matrix there are no complaints, all data is readable without any problems in any lighting.
Functionality and characteristics. The watch runs on its own Tizen platform, which is noticeably more convenient than Android Wear. There are fewer applications here, but they are quite enough for everyday use.
Like any fitness tracker, the watch can track steps, calories, and sleep. Interesting features include determining the lifting height, as well as the ability to compete with friends in the number of steps. To evaluate all the fitness capabilities of the watch, you need to use the S Health application, which is only available for the Galaxy series from Samsung. Such exclusivity is an undoubted disadvantage of the gadget.
The watch has GPS and Glonass, which can remember your route. Separately, I would like to note that there is a version with LTE, which will allow you to call directly from the watch without a smartphone. A pleasant advantage of the gadget is its long operating time, taking into account the huge number of functions that require battery power.
The third generation of guiaras has noticeably improved heart rate measurements, which is why the watch is included in our TOP. The heart rate monitor works correctly even during intense movement.
Advantages:
- display
- Availability of Wi-Fi and GPS
- convenient control
- MIL-810G protection in Frontier version
Flaws:
- Samsung's proprietary fitness app is only available for the Galaxy series
Verdict: An ideal option for everyday use at work, in the gym, on vacation, if you also have a Galaxy smartphone from Samsung.
Average price – $350
Estimated shelf life: up to 2 days
Polar is the 2nd company from this TOP, which came not from the world of technology, but from the world of sports watches. And this fact significantly influenced the Polar M600 model in terms of functionality.
Design and interface. The design of the watch is sporty and futuristic, the case is made of plastic, there are metal inserts on the sides, and the strap is made of silicone. The design is very much for everyone’s taste and will not appeal to everyone, plus the device is already quite bulky.
The main control is via the touch screen, there are also two mechanical buttons, on the left there is a “Stop” or “Back” button, below the display there is a button responsible for starting the workout.
Display juicy and bright, but in direct sunlight it is difficult to read data.
Functionality and characteristics. The watch is based on Android Wear, which means that more than 4,000 applications for various purposes will be available to the owner. Fitness capabilities are implemented through Google Fit and a special Polar Flow service, which records all the information about the training performed, and you can also schedule them there. The service is very good and will appeal to many athletes.
Runners and cyclists will appreciate the presence of a full-fledged GPS. Another nice feature of the gadget is that it is waterproof and can be submerged up to 10 meters, which is more than enough for a swimming pool.
Due to the 6-LED sensor, the heart rate monitor can compete in accuracy with chest-mounted heart rate meters. During testing, the heart rate monitor did not cause any complaints.
One of the unpleasant features is the short lifespan of the gadget, only 8 hours in training mode and 2 days in normal mode with Android, but with iPhone will only work for a day.
Advantages:
- Availability of Wi-Fi and GPS
- proprietary software for sports activities
Flaws:
- design for everyone
- short period of life
Verdict: A good option for professional athletes who need the most functional smartwatch.
Apple Watch Series 2
Average price – $400
Estimated life time: one day
It’s not for nothing that watches from the legendary brand are included in most reviews of smart watches and fitness trackers. Apple Watch Series 2, as a watch with a heart rate monitor, also did not disappoint.
Design and interface. The design is quite futuristic and not everyone will like it, but at the same time many will find it very attractive. It is presented in the shape of a rectangle with rounded corners. There are two control buttons on the right side. The number of varieties of straps is amazing in variety; the case itself is presented in the main material options: aluminum, steel, and ceramics. The updated version now has quick access to the necessary applications via a button, which makes control quite convenient.
Display juicy and bright, all data can be read without any problems in any weather. There is an automatic brightness adjustment sensor, the operation of which can be adjusted in the settings.
Functionality and characteristics. Apple Watch Series 2 is a true multifunctional machine among smartwatches, which can do almost everything that a modern smartwatch can provide. Briefly by functions:
- Ability to answer calls and receive messages;
- Tracking the physical activity of the wearer;
- Supports many additional applications from the App Store;
- Measuring calories burned, steps taken, heart rate
- Recording the route traveled using GPS
- Internet access via Wi-Fi
The watch boasts not only the usual Bluetooth and GPS modules, but also a Wi-Fi module that allows you to access the Internet directly from the gadget. The gadget is waterproof, it can be used in the pool, and even a separate functionality has been created for this purpose that tracks strokes.
All the perfection of the watch is killed by its lifetime, which is one day, which is an anti-record for this top, and it’s difficult to find smart watches in 2017 who live so little.
The app for measuring heart rate is very primitive and is suitable only for lovers of an active lifestyle, but not for professionals. But it is worth noting that The heart rate monitor works flawlessly. Moreover, an independent scientific study conducted at Stanford showed the error of the heart rate monitor on an exercise bike is only 2%, which is comparable to the electrocardiogram data; for walking, the figure was slightly higher than 2.5%.
Advantages:
- wide selection of applications
- Availability of GPS and Wi-Fi module
- juicy display
Flaws:
- very short period of life
- high price
Verdict: An excellent option for those iPhone owners who require the widest range of capabilities from a smartwatch.
Estimated life time: 9 days in watch mode, 11 hours in training mode with GPS
The ForeRunner series of watches is designed for running, as clearly evidenced by the name of the same name. The Garmin ForeRunner 235 is one of the best value for money running heart rate watches on the market. This model is suitable for both professionals and amateur runners who need much more than the functionality of a regular fitness tracker, but at the same time need a watch for everyday use.
Design and interface. The design of the ForeRunner 235 is made in a sporty style and they will not match a formal suit to emphasize the status of the wearer. But they will fit perfectly into any other wardrobe and not just sports ones.
Display quite large and bright, all notifications and data can be read without any problems, even in the sunniest weather. Control is carried out by 5 mechanical buttons, which is quite convenient in rainy weather. The entire interface is intuitive and does not require much time to understand. Russian language is supported.
Functionality and characteristics. The watch is equipped with GPS and the GLONASS system, which made it possible to introduce a wide range of capabilities; in addition to the classic data on steps, calories and sleep, it offers a number of other options. As they run, they can show an estimated finish time based on their current momentum. They will evaluate the training effect of the session. They will predict your best result based on the data already received. They will give recommendations for post-workout rest. Supports cycling training.
Also, many will find it useful to assess VO2 max to assess the effectiveness of the training process in athletics.
Additional amenities include smart notifications and music control on your smartphone. This is also the only smartwatch with a heart rate monitor suitable for this review.
Heart rate monitor operation does not cause any complaints even with intensive training. It is possible to track heart rate zones.
Advantages:
- Availability of GPS/Glonass
- Windows Phone support
- advanced features for running training
Flaws:
- not suitable for a formal suit
- lack of app store and internal memory
Verdict: An excellent option for those who are engaged in professional running training.
Leading a healthy lifestyle has now become not only useful, but also fashionable. Everyone wants to train with health benefits, and this is almost impossible without taking into account the individual’s individual indications during training. A sports watch in the form of a bracelet with a heart rate monitor, pedometer and blood pressure monitor will help you with this.
Advantages
It is almost impossible to assess your physical condition objectively on your own, without the presence of certain instruments. It is for this purpose that mankind has invented many gadgets that simplify this procedure. But carrying a bunch of devices with you to workout is simply inconvenient, which is where sports watches with a heart rate monitor, pedometer and blood pressure monitor come to the fore.
In this case, the real gadget is classified as a so-called universal and multifunctional “smart” watch model.
The advantage of watches is their versatility. They have a number of capabilities:
- alarm clock;
- A pedometer helps you monitor the distance traveled;
- help set the correct pace of training, as well as calculate the time for rest;
- A tonometer allows you to measure blood pressure;
- heart rate measurement;
- a watch that counts calories burned during exercise;
- watch-phone (you can make and answer calls directly from your wrist);
- watch sensors recognize daily activity: analyze your condition when you run, walk and even sleep;
- have a shockproof and moisture resistant coating.
Popular models
There are quite a lot of varieties of sports watch models with a heart rate monitor, pedometer and blood pressure monitor, some of them are worth mentioning:
- Watch in the form of a fitness bracelet. Outwardly they resemble an ordinary bracelet, they look beautiful and unobtrusive on the hand. They have a pedometer, heart rate monitor, and motion sensor. They help track physical activity, control heartbeat, calories, and take into account the quality of rest. Equipped with multimedia capabilities.
- Watch with calorie counter. This model is very popular among women, as it allows for clear weight control, counts calories burned taking into account the measurement of the fat layer, and counts the distance covered, length and number of steps taken.
- Watches with smart wearable technology capabilities. They have a large number of options: running sensor, heart rate monitor, GPS sensor, tonometer. They allow not only to keep track of the physical indications of their owner, but also allow one to navigate in space. This electronic gadget can maintain operation for 30 hours without recharging.
- Fitness watch with GPS function. This model is distinguished by a number of specific features: it controls the level of difficulty of physical activity, measures heart rate, analyzes movement speed and calculates calories burned. The watch also has a built-in GPS navigator and 3D compass.
Functions
The range of functions of sports watches can hardly be overestimated, because they are a unique gadget that combines the work of several devices at once. Let’s take a closer look at them:
- Availability of a heart rate monitor for running. It controls heart rate.
- Availability of a tonometer. It is used to measure blood pressure levels.
- Availability of a pedometer. It measures the number and length of steps during exercise, whether walking or running.
More advanced and expensive products have the most expanded range of functions, including the following:
- a calorie burn counter allows you to monitor the quality of your workout;
- A GPS navigator allows you to navigate in space. A model with this function will be very useful on walks and tourist trips.
- built-in flashlight for convenience;
- a stopwatch makes it possible to record intermediate training results;
- The timer counts limited, specified periods of time for performing an exercise.
- alarm function.
How accurate?
Product manufacturers regularly work to improve the accuracy of watch measurements. And in many ways they succeeded, since most users note that the watch quite accurately shows the physiological indicators of their health, distance and other characteristics. But again, there is no 100% result.
Some owners of the accessory indicate deviations from the actual indicators measured by specialized instruments.
Main selection criteria
The range of sports watches is very large; first of all, you need to decide for what purpose you are purchasing the product (for running, cycling, fitness, or to monitor your health), and based on this, focus on the functions it should have.
When purchasing a sports watch, you should pay attention to such characteristics as:
- Operating time without recharging. If the model has a large set of functions, then, accordingly, quite a lot of energy will be spent on ensuring its operation. This should also be taken into account when choosing a product.
- Data accuracy. A very important indicator. Since the quality of your training, and, consequently, your health, will depend on the reliability of the data, since a sports watch is not just a device associated with calculating distance, it is a device that measures pulse, heart rate, rest time and other physiological characteristics your body.
- Shockproof and waterproof. Anything can happen during training: impacts, precipitation, after all, this is a sport, so these characteristics must be at their best.
- Alert sound: sound or vibration.
- Design. Also an important factor when choosing a model. A watch is, first of all, a fashion accessory that should emphasize the status and individuality of its owner. Sports watches are also no exception; their designs can be very diverse and exclusive.
For example, women's sports models combine both sophisticated design and a variety of important functional characteristics.
Review of the best
The following models have earned a reputation as the best in the sports watch market:
- Model Polar RCX5 SD RUN. This manufacturing company regularly surprises customers with its “smart” technology, and watches from this company are no exception. The model has a wide range of options: heart rate monitor, running sensor, GPS sensor. It has a fairly high accuracy of readings.
- Model Suunto Quest GPS. Not inferior to Polar in basic characteristics. Its functions include the following: heart rate sensor, GPS tracker, USB adapter, heart rate monitor, blood pressure monitor, calorie counting. It has the function of monitoring the state of the body and allows you to draw up graphs of achieved results.
- Suunto M5 model. This model is unusual; it allows the owner to independently modify the sports watch with the necessary sensors, which is extremely convenient, since it does not oblige the owner to use the imposed options, but allows them to be changed to suit themselves.
- Omron Project Zero 2.0. This is a unique smart watch model. A “smart” model that allows you to measure the basic vital signs of its owner, such as blood pressure, heart rate. The gadget monitors the body's activity, as well as the duration and quality of sleep, measures blood pressure and heart rate.
Blood pressure data is entered manually and needs to be updated regularly to ensure the most accurate readings. They should be worn on the left hand and so that the back cover fits tightly to the hand, this way the readings can be read more accurately. The more carefully you follow all the recommendations specified in the instructions for the watch, the more reliable results you will receive when using it.
Smartwatches have revitalized the watch market, offering users a range of new and useful features. One such feature is a heart rate monitor, or heart rate monitor.
According to a study conducted by scientists at Stanford University and the Swedish School of Sports and Health, the Apple Watch was found to have the lowest accuracy in determining the accuracy of a user's heart rate.
The experiment was carried out in comparison with the stationary method - ECG. Despite the +/- 5% margin of error, Apple's smartwatch showed a minimal deviation of just 2%, unlike the other wearables in the test.
One of the most important elements of the Apple Watch Series 4 smartwatch is the set of four heart rate sensors built into the back of the case. Researchers at the University of California (San Francisco) determined that the Apple Watch was able to detect heart problems with 97% accuracy.
The built-in GPS system is used to measure pace, distance and speed when playing sports and cycling. But the main feature is waterproofing. The new model is waterproof up to 50 meters (5 ATM) and can be worn while showering and even swimming. And for runners, a special version of the Apple Watch Nike+ has been released with some built-in Nike features.
Characteristics:
- AMOLED, 1.5″, 272×340 (290 ppi) and 1.65″, 312x390 (304 ppi)
- WiFi
- Bluetooth 4.0LE
- moisture protection 50 m (5 ATM), IPX7, can be used in a swimming pool
- Light sensor
- battery life 18 hours
- Compatibility: iOS only
Conclusion. Apple Watch Series 4 is designed with a focus on sports and fitness, and a variety of sizes and colors will allow both women and men to choose from. They offer the best heart rate monitor without a chest strap, earning the top spot in our list of top sports smartwatches with heart rate and pedometer.
Prices range from $269 to $699, offering a variety of customizations and product designs.
Video: Apple Watch Series 4
Garmin Phoenix 5
Garmin Fenix 5, introduced by the company in January 2017, is equipped with a whole package of functions, as well as optical sensors from Elevate, which are capable of tracking almost all user actions.
The Garmin Fenix 5's heart rate monitoring accuracy has been verified through testing by a staff member at Androidauthority. He compared the performance of the Fenix 5 heart rate monitor to the Wahoo TICKR X chest strap, which he has found to be very reliable.
Keep in mind that the Garmin optical heart rate monitor is not designed for pool use. It works great for training and outdoor sports.
During an 8km run, Garmin recorded a maximum heart rate of 175 beats per minute, while the TICKR X recorded 182. Typically, the heart rate sensors on watches deviate by 5 beats per minute during high-intensity training, although this does not happen that often and does not become problematic. In this workout, the Fenix 5 recorded an average heart rate of 152, while the Wahoo TICKR X recorded an average heart rate of 163, and the watch took a while to register a heart rate above 150 bpm, but the chest strap reported almost immediately.
If you want more accurate results, you can use the Garmin Fenix 5 in combination with ANT+ or Bluetooth Smart heart rate straps.
In terms of technical specifications, they include:
- 1.2-inch color LCD with 240x240 resolution, non-touch (5S model has a screen resolution of 218x218)
- WiFi
- ANT+
- Bluetooth 4.0LE
- Battery life up to 2 weeks in smartwatch mode (depending on settings), up to 24 hours in GPS mode and up to 100 hours in UltraTrac power saving mode
The new line, which includes the Fenix 5 and Fenix 5S models, offers 64 MB of memory, with 54 MB available for use. It is worth noting the Fenix 5X model, which has 12 GB for installing maps where you can navigate along the route.
Conclusion. Garmin Fenix 5 positions itself as a running watch and will make your workout a pleasure. It can act as the best men's sports watch with heart rate monitor and pedometer.
Prices range from $600 to $850, depending on the model: F5, F5S or F5X. Read more about this line.
Video: Garmin Phoenix 5
The Polar M430 is an all-in-one sports device that delivers wrist-based heart rate measurements during workouts and runs with location capabilities, as well as tracking metrics for daily activity, steps, calories and sleep. Paired with the Polar Flow server, the M430 turns into a trusted coach that can provide personalized feedback, an adaptive training plan and live guidance to athletes at different stages of their training.
Polar M430 is equipped with performance monitoring features such as training guide, recovery analysis, vibration intervals and more.
This model can use wrist-based heart rate without a chest strap and offers 6 LED elements for optical heart rate measurement, built-in GPS and Bluetooth smartphone connectivity.
Over the course of a month, an employee of the CardioCritic website tested the Polar M430 watch in parallel with the Suunto Spartan Sport HR and Garmin Edge 820 chest straps. The results were amazing. There was virtually no noticeable difference in heart rate readings using chest straps and sports watches. The peaks and valleys of the Polar M430 graph follow the heart rate tracked using the chest strap with extreme accuracy.
Technical characteristics include:
- monochrome 1.4-inch screen with a resolution of 128x128
- WiFi
- GPS (SiRFInstantFix satellite communication technology)
- Bluetooth 4.1
- moisture protection 30 m (3 ATM)
- 8 MB memory
- vibration signal
- activity sensor
- 240 mAh battery with 8-hour service with working sensors
Conclusion. Polar has created a strong rival to Garmin, a GPS and heart rate monitor sports watch with essential features for runners, which confidently took a respectable third place in the ranking. Thus, in this list, these are the best heart rate monitor watches without a chest strap.
The Polar M430 is priced at $229.
Video: Polar M430
Suunto Spartan Sport was launched in March 2017 as the ultimate multi-sport watch for sports enthusiasts that require speed, distance and heart rate monitoring, including triathlon.
This is the best heart rate watch, offering 16 hours of training time and 100m water resistance, plus a variety of features and training options for each of the 80 sports modes, allowing you to customize training metrics to suit your personal needs.
They guarantee precision and comfort without the need for chest straps. However, to achieve exceptional heart rate accuracy, they can be paired with an external heart rate sensor via Bluetooth.
The Spartan Sport heart rate and pedometer sports watch monitors your heart beat 24/7 and is compatible with the Suunto Smart Touch Strap to track your heart rate while swimming. In addition to location support, it is possible to add POI navigation waypoints.
Characteristics:
- color touch display with a resolution of 320x300
- GPS and GLONASS
- digital compass
- heart rate monitor
- pedometer
- moisture protection 100 m (10 ATM)
- compatible with iOS/Android and Suunto Movescount service
- battery life 16 hours
Conclusion. This device comes in at number four and can be considered one of the best running watches with heart rate monitor. Because they use a top-notch heart rate sensor from Valencell, trusted by many leading brands, for the most accurate readings.
The Spartan Sport Wrist HR retails for $522.
Video: Suunto Spartan Sport Wrist HR
Sports smartwatches with a heart rate monitor have optical sensors that can read your heart rate, allowing athletes, and runners in particular, to monitor their health. However, so far, none of the smartwatch heart rate monitors measure heart rate as accurately as chest straps that fit tightly directly to the heart do.
If you have already purchased any of the above watches with an optical sensor, please share your experience in the comments.
A fitness bracelet with a pedometer is a compact device with which you can easily and quickly count the number of steps taken. The body of the accessory is made of aluminum (or other metal) or plastic, and the strap, the length of which can be adjusted, is made of rubber, silicone, plastic or leather. Smart bracelets with a pedometer are compatible with mobile devices that run on the Android, IOS and Windows Phone platforms.
As a rule, on the front side of fitness bracelets equipped with a pedometer, there is an AMOLED, OLED, E-ink display, which displays information about the measurements taken. In addition to the number of steps taken, the gadget can also calculate the number of calories burned during physical activity, determine the phase of sleep, which is necessary to improve its quality, and set a smart alarm clock. Many models are additionally equipped with a gyroscope, heart rate monitor, thermometer and atmospheric pressure sensor.
Pairing with a mobile device is carried out via a built-in Bluetooth module. Thanks to it, the bracelet can send the user notifications about incoming and missed calls, messages received via email and social network chats, as well as SMS.
Where to buy a fitness bracelet with a pedometer?
A large selection of fitness bracelets with a pedometer, made in different designs and colors, is presented in the catalog of the Eldorado online store. We offer favorable prices for gadgets, as well as delivery and pickup in Moscow and other cities of Russia.
